Review Process Policy

Policy Statement

JAM-EKIS employs a double-blind peer-review system: authors’ and reviewers’ identities are concealed from one another during review. Editorial assessment prioritizes originality, relevance to journal scope, methodological rigor, clarity, ethical compliance, and scholarly contribution.

Stages of Review

Stage 1: Submission

Authors submit manuscripts through the JAM-EKIS OJS platform according to the Author Guidelines and required declarations.

Stage 2: Initial Editorial Screening

Editors assess scope, formatting, completeness, originality and similarity concerns, scientific merit, and ethical compliance. Unsuitable submissions may be returned or desk-rejected.

Stage 3: Reviewer Assignment

The journal generally seeks assessments from two to three suitably qualified, independent reviewers, subject to actual editorial practice and reviewer availability.

Stage 4: Double-Blind Peer Review

Reviewers evaluate novelty, objectives, literature, theoretical framework, design, methods, data analysis, findings, discussion, conclusion, references, and ethics. Reviews should be constructive and evidence-based.

Stage 5: Editorial Decision

Possible decisions are Accept, Minor Revision, Major Revision, or Reject. Reviewer recommendations inform but do not replace independent editorial judgment.

Stage 6: Revision

Authors submit a revised manuscript and point-by-point response explaining their changes or justified disagreements. Further review may be requested.

Stage 7: Final Evaluation

The editor confirms that necessary changes have been addressed and that publication requirements are satisfied.

Stage 8: Production and Publication

Accepted articles undergo copyediting, layout, proof review, and final publication preparation.

Reviewer Responsibilities

  • Evaluate objectively and respect confidential manuscript material.
  • Disclose conflicts and decline assignments where independence is compromised.
  • Provide reasoned feedback and notify editors about delays.
  • Report apparent plagiarism, duplicate publication, manipulation, or other ethical concerns.
  • Do not exploit unpublished work or share it with unauthorized parties.
  • Do not upload confidential manuscripts to external AI tools without appropriate authorization.

Editor Responsibilities

Editors must appoint competent reviewers, manage conflicts, protect review confidentiality, address unethical conduct, and base decisions on scholarship rather than personal or institutional influence. Manuscripts involving editorial board members should receive independent handling.

Confidentiality and Anonymity

Reviewer identities are not disclosed to authors under the double-blind model, and authors should prepare anonymized manuscripts according to submission guidelines. Editorial correspondence and manuscript files are confidential except where disclosure is authorized or required.

Appeals

Authors may appeal decisions in writing when they identify a significant factual error, procedural irregularity, or other substantive basis for reconsideration. The Editor-in-Chief may obtain independent advice; an appeal does not guarantee acceptance.

Commitment to Quality

JAM-EKIS continuously seeks fair, constructive, and rigorous peer review to support trustworthy scholarship and responsible editorial practice.